Skip to content
Examined Doctrine

Council of Ephesus on Election & predestination

431 · ECUMENICAL COUNCIL · DOCUMENT, NOT A PERSON
READ IN A PRIMARY SOURCENO POSITION FOUND
NO STANCE — AND WHY

No position located on this map

Searched in the sources read for this figure and not found. A limit of the reading rather than a claim about the figure — a source not yet read could settle it.

"if any metropolitan of a province ... has adopted or shall hereafter adopt the doctrines of Celestius, this man shall have no power over the bishops of the province."
Canon 1

THE POSITION

Unlike the fourth-century councils, Ephesus is not innocent of this question — it condemned Celestius, Pelagius's leading disciple, by name, and so ratified the Western condemnation of Pelagianism at the ecumenical level. But the condemnation is by person, not by exposition. Nothing in the canons read here, or in Cyril's Twelve Anathemas, states on what basis God chooses. Augustine had died the previous year having written On the Predestination of the Saints; the category was fully available in 431 and this council did not take it up.

WHAT OTHERS HOLD HERE

Unconditional — grounded in God's free choiceAQUINAS · AUGUSTINE · VODDIE BAUCHAM · CALVIN · JONATHAN EDWARDS · TIM KELLER · SECOND LONDON BAPTIST CONFESSION · LUTHER · JOHN MACARTHUR · GAVIN ORTLUND · JOHN OWEN · JUSTIN PETERS · JOHN PIPER · JOHN DUNS SCOTUS · R.C. SPROUL · CHARLES HADDON SPURGEON · WESTMINSTER CONFESSION · GEORGE WHITEFIELD · ZWINGLI
Conditional — grounded in foreseen faithJACOBUS ARMINIUS · CHRYSOSTOM · CHARLES GRANDISON FINNEY · PHILIP MELANCHTHON · WESLEY
Affirmed, held alongside real human responsibility, treated as non-dividingBILLY GRAHAM · JOSH HOWERTON
See all 36 figures on election & predestination →

ABOUT THIS FIGURE

Affirmed Mary as Theotokos and the unity of Christ's person against Nestorius. Closed creed-making beyond Nicaea, and condemned the Pelagian Celestius.

4 OF 5 POSITIONS QUOTED
Everything Ephesus holds →
Cite this page

"Council of Ephesus on Election & predestination", Examined Doctrine, July 2026 edition, https://examineddoctrine.com/position/ephesus-431/election (archived at https://examineddoctrine.com/editions/2026-07/position/ephesus-431/election).

How citation works here