Skip to content
Examined Doctrine

Pope Pius V on the Lord's Supper

1504 – 1572 · ROMAN CATHOLIC
READ IN A PRIMARY SOURCEAFFIRMS
STANCE

The elements become Christ's body and blood

This conversion, then, is so effected that the whole substance of the bread is changed by the power of God into the whole substance of the body of Christ, and the whole substance of the wine into the whole substance of His blood, and this, without any change in our Lord Himself.
Roman Catechism (1566), Part II, The Eucharist, "Transubstantiation a Total Conversion" (McHugh & Callan trans., 1923) ↗

THE POSITION

The whole substance of bread and wine is changed into Christ's body and blood, and the Church "most appropriately" calls this transubstantiation. The catechism keeps the reception distinct from the change: some receive the sacrament only sacramentally, some only in spirit, and those who receive it both ways, having first proved themselves, "derive from the Eucharist those most abundant fruits."

SCRIPTURE
MATTHEW 26:26 · BSB

26 While they were eating, Jesus took bread, spoke a blessing and broke it, and gave it to the disciples, saying, “Take and eat; this is My body.”

3 OTHERS HOLD THIS

AquinasWilliam of OckhamJohn Duns Scotus
True bodily presence in, with, and under the elementsLUTHER · PHILIP MELANCHTHON
Real but spiritual presence, received by faithAUGUSTINE · CALVIN · JONATHAN EDWARDS · TIM KELLER · SECOND LONDON BAPTIST CONFESSION · JOHN OWEN · R.C. SPROUL · WESLEY · WESTMINSTER CONFESSION
A memorial and sign; no presence in the elementsCHARLES GRANDISON FINNEY · M. HEISER · JOHN MACARTHUR · WILLIAM TYNDALE · ZWINGLI
Truly the body and blood, with no account of the modeBASIL THE GREAT · CHRYSOSTOM · IRENAEUS
See all 32 figures on the lord's supper →

ABOUT THIS FIGURE

Michele Ghislieri, a Dominican friar and inquisitor, was pope from 1566 to 1572 and carried the Council of Trent's decrees into practice. Under his authority came the Roman Catechism (1566), the reformed Breviary (1568) and Missal (1570), and the bull Ex omnibus afflictionibus (1567) on the teaching of Michael Baius; he also named Thomas Aquinas a Doctor of the Church. He wrote little theology of his own, so this entry rests on what he promulgated: the Roman Catechism, read in the McHugh and Callan translation, a commission's work issued by his order, and the 1567 bull in Deferrari's translation of Denzinger.

14 OF 19 POSITIONS QUOTED
Everything Pope Pius V holds →
Cite this page

"Pope Pius V on the Lord's Supper", Examined Doctrine, July 2026 edition, https://examineddoctrine.com/position/pius-v/lords-supper (archived at https://examineddoctrine.com/editions/2026-07/position/pius-v/lords-supper).

How citation works here