Skip to content
Examined Doctrine

John Duns Scotus on Continuation of spiritual gifts

C. 1266 – 1308 · SCHOLASTIC
NOT LOCATED IN A SOURCEQUESTION NOT FRAMED
NO STANCE — AND WHY

The question is not framed in these terms

This locus asks in categories that came later. Assigning a stance would answer on the figure's behalf, so the summary records what was addressed instead.

THE POSITION

Anachronistic. The continuationist and cessationist positions are shaped by a post-Reformation argument about whether the miraculous gifts ceased with the apostles; the question is not put in these terms in his period.

WHY THERE IS NO QUOTATIONNo quotations. Scotus died in 1308 and the Latin is public domain, but the usable English translations are modern and in copyright, so these positions are paraphrased from standard scholarly accounts rather than reproduced.

WHAT OTHERS HOLD HERE

Yes, the gifts continueATHANASIUS · BASIL THE GREAT · THE CHURCH OF ELEVEN22 STATEMENT OF FAITH · JOSH HOWERTON · IRENAEUS · JOHN PIPER
No, they ceased with the apostolic ageVODDIE BAUCHAM · CALVIN · CHRYSOSTOM · JONATHAN EDWARDS · JOHN MACARTHUR · JOHN OWEN · JUSTIN PETERS · R.C. SPROUL · GEORGE WHITEFIELD
Open in principle, cautious in practiceAUGUSTINE · BILLY GRAHAM · M. HEISER · TIM KELLER · LUTHER · GAVIN ORTLUND
See all 28 figures on continuation of spiritual gifts →

ABOUT THIS FIGURE

Franciscan, the Subtle Doctor. Argued for the univocity of being and for a will free in its own right rather than moved by the intellect's judgment — the point where the Franciscan schools part from Aquinas.

READ ACROSS 18 LOCI, NONE QUOTED
Everything John Duns Scotus holds →
Cite this page

"John Duns Scotus on Continuation of spiritual gifts", Examined Doctrine, July 2026 edition, https://examineddoctrine.com/position/scotus/spiritual-gifts (archived at https://examineddoctrine.com/editions/2026-07/position/scotus/spiritual-gifts).

How citation works here