Skip to content
Examined Doctrine

Council of Trent on Extent of the atonement

1545 – 1563 · ROMAN CATHOLIC COUNCIL · DOCUMENT, NOT A PERSON
READ IN A PRIMARY SOURCEAFFIRMS°
STANCE

Sufficient for all, efficient for the elect

But, though He died for all, yet do not all receive the benefit of His death, but those only unto whom the merit of His passion is communicated.
Session VI (1547), Decree on Justification, chapter 3 ↗

THE POSITION

Christ died for all, but only those to whom the merit of his passion is communicated receive its benefit. The same chapter says people would never be justified "if they were not born again in Christ." That is the distinction between the death's worth, which reaches all, and its fruit, which reaches those reborn. The decree does not limit Christ's death to the elect.

5 OTHERS HOLD THIS

AquinasCalvinPope Pius VJohn Duns ScotusCharles Haddon Spurgeon
Definite — for the elect, effectuallyVODDIE BAUCHAM · MATT CHANDLER · JONATHAN EDWARDS · SECOND LONDON BAPTIST CONFESSION · JOHN MACARTHUR · JOHN OWEN · JOHN PIPER · R.C. SPROUL · WILLIAM TYNDALE · WESTMINSTER CONFESSION · GEORGE WHITEFIELD
Universal — for all, applied on faithJACOBUS ARMINIUS · ATHANASIUS · CHRYSOSTOM · CHARLES GRANDISON FINNEY · BILLY GRAHAM · LUTHER · PHILIP MELANCHTHON · WESLEY
Never framed in these termsAUGUSTINE · JOSH HOWERTON · NICAEA I · ZWINGLI
See all 34 figures on extent of the atonement →

ABOUT THIS FIGURE

Met in twenty-five sessions over three periods, at Trento in northern Italy except for two sessions held at Bologna in 1547. Called by Paul III and closed under Pius IV. It answered the Reformation point by point: Scripture and tradition, the canon, original sin, justification and the seven sacraments. From the Sixth Session on, each subject is set out in chapters and then in canons ending "let him be anathema." The Catholic Church counts it the nineteenth ecumenical council; the Orthodox and Protestant churches do not count it as ecumenical. Read here in J. Waterworth's 1848 translation.

15 OF 15 POSITIONS QUOTED
Everything Trent holds →
Cite this page

"Council of Trent on Extent of the atonement", Examined Doctrine, July 2026 edition, https://examineddoctrine.com/position/trent/atonement-extent (archived at https://examineddoctrine.com/editions/2026-07/position/trent/atonement-extent).

How citation works here