Skip to content
Examined Doctrine

Pope Pius V on Original sin & the human will

1504 – 1572 · ROMAN CATHOLIC
READ IN A PRIMARY SOURCEAFFIRMS
STANCE

Nature wounded but not destroyed; grace perfects it

unhappy man went astray, and lost not only original justice, with which he had been supernaturally gifted and adorned by God, but also obscured that singular inclination toward virtue which had been implanted in his soul.
Roman Catechism (1566), Part IV, The Third Petition, "Man's Proneness to Act Against God's Will" (McHugh & Callan trans., 1923) ↗

THE POSITION

The fall cost the supernatural gift of original justice and wounded, but did not destroy, the nature beneath it: the inclination toward virtue was "obscured", and without grace no one can do what is acceptable to God. The sharper claim that the unaided will can only sin is one he condemned. "Free will, without the help of God's grace, has only power for sin" is the 27th of the propositions of Michael Baius censured in Ex omnibus afflictionibus (1567, Denzinger 1027). The bull's censure allows that some propositions "could be maintained in some way" while condemning them in the sense their authors intended, so it rules out Baius's reading rather than every strong Augustinian sentence.

SCRIPTURE
GENESIS 8:21 · BSB

21 When the LORD smelled the pleasing aroma, He said in His heart, “Never again will I curse the ground because of man, even though every inclination of his heart is evil from his youth. And never again will I destroy all living creatures as I have done.

6 OTHERS HOLD THIS

AquinasAthanasiusEphesusIgnatius of LoyolaWilliam of OckhamJohn Duns Scotus
Will in bondage; needs sovereign grace to be freedAUGUSTINE · VODDIE BAUCHAM · CALVIN · MATT CHANDLER · JONATHAN EDWARDS · THE CHURCH OF ELEVEN22 STATEMENT OF FAITH · M. HEISER · JOSH HOWERTON · TIM KELLER · SECOND LONDON BAPTIST CONFESSION · LUTHER · JOHN MACARTHUR · JOHN OWEN · JUSTIN PETERS · JOHN PIPER · R.C. SPROUL · CHARLES HADDON SPURGEON · WILLIAM TYNDALE · WESTMINSTER CONFESSION · GEORGE WHITEFIELD · ZWINGLI
Depraved, but prevenient grace restores ability to respondJACOBUS ARMINIUS · BILLY GRAHAM · PHILIP MELANCHTHON · WESLEY
Free will substantially intact; God and man cooperateBASIL THE GREAT · CHRYSOSTOM · CHARLES GRANDISON FINNEY · IRENAEUS
See all 40 figures on original sin & the human will →

ABOUT THIS FIGURE

Michele Ghislieri, a Dominican friar and inquisitor, was pope from 1566 to 1572 and carried the Council of Trent's decrees into practice. Under his authority came the Roman Catechism (1566), the reformed Breviary (1568) and Missal (1570), and the bull Ex omnibus afflictionibus (1567) on the teaching of Michael Baius; he also named Thomas Aquinas a Doctor of the Church. He wrote little theology of his own, so this entry rests on what he promulgated: the Roman Catechism, read in the McHugh and Callan translation, a commission's work issued by his order, and the 1567 bull in Deferrari's translation of Denzinger.

14 OF 19 POSITIONS QUOTED
Everything Pope Pius V holds →
Cite this page

"Pope Pius V on Original sin & the human will", Examined Doctrine, July 2026 edition, https://examineddoctrine.com/position/pius-v/original-sin (archived at https://examineddoctrine.com/editions/2026-07/position/pius-v/original-sin).

How citation works here